21 Mar 2025

Level 2 Data: How to Read the Order Book

by |

 

 

Decoding Market Secrets: A Comprehensive Guide to Order Book Analysis for Retail Traders (Featuring ASOS)

Introduction: The order book – that ever-changing list of buy and sell orders – is a window into the heart of market activity. This guide will provide an in-depth exploration of order book analysis, helping retail traders understand market mechanics, identify potential manipulation, and use Level 2 data effectively. We'll use examples featuring ASOS (ASC), considering a scenario where a recent earnings update acts as a catalyst for price movement, and short interest exceeds 5.5%.

1. Understanding the Structure of the Order Book (ASOS Example)

The order book compiles real-time buy (bid) and sell (offer/ask) orders for a specific security, revealing supply and demand at various price points.

Key Order Book Terms

Term Definition
Bid The price buyers are willing to pay for a security. In our ASC example, bids are found around the 310.0 - 310.6 region.
Offer (Ask) The price sellers are willing to accept for a security. In our ASC example, offers cluster around the 311.6 region.
Spread The difference between the highest bid and lowest offer; tighter spreads imply higher liquidity. ASC  has a spread around 1 p
Buy Depth The total volume of shares available at all bid prices. Hypothetically, ASC shows 74,975 volume on the buy side.
Sell Depth The total volume of shares available at all offer prices. ASC has 72,908 volume on the sell side.
VWAP (Volume-Weighted Average Price) The average price weighted by volume over a specific period. This reveals whether ASC's trades are above or below the day's average.
EMS (Exchange Market Size) The standard size of trades on an exchange, a benchmark for liquidity. ASC might have an EMS around 2000
AT Volume Trades executed automatically (algorithmic), off-book, implying reduced manual oversight.

Analyzing a The ASOS (ASC) Order Book

The example order book reveals:

  • Bid and Offer Dynamics: The highest bid and lowest offer indicate immediate buying/selling interest.
  • Volume at Each Price Level: Detailing shares available at varied prices (e.g., 6000 volume at 302.2).
  • Buy/Sell Depth: Highlights imbalance; if Buy depth is high (43), there may be strong buying interest.

AT versus OB (Automated Trades vs. Off-Book)

  1. Off-Book Transparency: High off-book volume requires caution; diminished transparency complicates direct analysis.
  2. Algorithmic Impact: AT volume shows the sway of automated systems, influencing tradings and price discovery.
  3. VWAP and Assessment: As a crucial tool, VWAP signals "fair prices" considering completed ASC actions in the trading period.

Role of Other Important Terms in the Order Book:

  1. Yellow Tape. Real-time recording of the action and what prices occurred.
  2. Auctions. The price setting mechanism during start and close of the day.

2. Navigating the Tricky Terrain: Order Book Manipulation Tactics (ASOS)

Order book manipulation twists real data to influence price or mislead other traders. Tactics can include:

1. Spoofing

  • What It Is: Inflating bids or offers by placing large "fake" ASOS orders, only to cancel them rapidly.
  • Purpose: Baiting others into thinking buying/selling interest is high.
  • Example: Huge, yet fleeting ASOS bid creates sudden artificial appeal.

2. Layering

  • What It Is: Creating multiple, staggered ASOS orders to add depth to certain price levels.
  • Purpose: Building impressions of great interest, when these orders can suddenly vanish.
  • Example: Orders stacked at close intervals, all cancelled as needed.

3. Iceberg Orders

  • What It Is: Hiding substantial ASOS orders using smaller increments.
  • Purpose: Conceal true volume.
  • Example: Showing just a tiny percentage of large volumes for ASOS sales.

4. Stop-Loss Hunting

  • What It Is: Driving prices to where numerous stop-loss orders get triggered.
  • Purpose: Fabricate artificial volatility
  • Example: Force sell-offs near key ASOS chart areas.

5. Stepping on the Bids/Walking Down the Price

  • What It Is: Lowering bids rapidly to drop security
  • Purpose: Accelerate downside, exploiting buyers and those on a stop-loss
  • Example: Continuously low offers.

6. Quote Stuffing

  • What It Is: Overwhelming the system with quick order adjustments, hindering reaction.
  • Purpose: Securing informational edge.
  • Example: Level 2 distortions impacting real trades.

7. Wash Trading

  • What It Is: Simultaneously buying and selling same shares to create volume.
  • Purpose: Deceiving others.
  • Example: Duplicating similar buy/sell in ASOS without real transfer.

The Question of Market Makers (ASOS): Are ASOS Market Makers Manipulating?

Market Makers should enable trades while earning from wide spreads. There are consistent debates that the MMs actually engage in price manipulation via actions like the one previously mentioned. There is no consensus.

If ASOS VWAP values reflect the prices are unfairly tilted, market manipulation may be suspected.

Whether this is retail paranoia cannot be proven without a regulatory investigation.

3. Level 2 Data: A Trader's Toolkit for ASOS

With Level 2 analysis in place, one can see:

  1. Levels: Support and Resistance
  2. Shifts in Market sentiment. This means looking at trades as they reflect bullish or bearish views

SHORT SQUEEZES (ASOS Details)

  1. Spikes: Unusual burst action with volume
  2. Breaking Through: Resistance areas surpassed quickly.
  3. Short Covering: Large buy activities are combined.

If one combines Level 2 with a deeper assessment, with a sudden surge of ASOS buyers then a SHORT squeeze may be occurring.

ASOS Earnings Report Catalyst and Short Squeeze

With 5.5% short interest reported: a positive report has created a panic buy and a short squeeze scenario

Using Level 2 for ASOS Trading:

Understanding if trades exceeding 65 GBP versus initial shorts near 72-73 GBP is the real art.

4. Level 2: Pros and Cons (The ASOS Debate)

The tool has benefits but avoid seeing it as foolproof.

Benefits

  1. Show the overall dynamics in ASOS trading
  2. Show potential levels
  3. Helps assess ASC patterns like spoofing
  4. Stronger when applied for intraday analysis

Drawbacks

  1. Overload of Information which is not useful
  2. Does not account of hidden orders from Dark Pools etc
  3. Needs real experience to avoid harm
  4. Access comes at a premium

Conclusion

Applying the discussed knowledge should improve analysis. Confirm all decisions to reduce harm.

Disclaimer: While this offers insights, seek experts. All trading has risk and should be applied with knowledge and care.

 

 

Can Price Be Manipulated in Low-Volume Shares?

Yes, price manipulation in low-volume shares is possible, particularly during quiet trading periods. Here's a detailed analysis of how this can occur, the mechanisms involved, and its implications.

Mechanisms of Price Manipulation

1. Liquidity Gaps

Low-volume stocks inherently have limited liquidity, meaning fewer buyers and sellers actively trading. This creates wider bid-ask spreads and makes it easier for large orders to influence the price significantly. For example:

  • A trader or institution can place a large buy or sell order to move the price to desired levels.

  • Thin liquidity allows smaller capital to create disproportionate price movements46.

2. Stop-Loss Hunting

Stop-loss hunting involves deliberately moving the price to trigger stop-loss orders placed by retail traders. This is often done at psychologically significant levels like round numbers or recent highs/lows:

  • During off-peak hours (e.g., early morning or late afternoon), liquidity is thinner, making it easier for manipulators to push prices5.

  • Algorithms used by institutional players can identify clusters of stop-loss orders and execute trades to hit these levels, causing cascading effects as stops are triggered5.

3. Pump-and-Dump Schemes

In low-volume stocks, manipulators may artificially inflate the price (pump) through misleading news or aggressive buying before selling their positions at a profit (dump). The lack of liquidity exacerbates this issue as fewer participants can counteract the manipulation46.

Key Characteristics of Low-Volume Stocks

Feature Impact on Price Manipulation
Limited Liquidity Easier to move prices with small capital due to fewer participants.
Wider Bid-Ask Spread Allows manipulators to exploit gaps between buy and sell orders.
Volatility Prices can swing dramatically with relatively small trades.
Off-Peak Hours Lower activity makes manipulation easier during quiet periods.

How Manipulation Can Be Used to Run Stops or Close Positions

  1. Running Stops:

    • Manipulators push the price below support levels or above resistance levels where retail traders commonly place stop-loss orders.

    • This triggers a cascade of sell or buy orders, amplifying the price movement temporarily5.

  2. Closing Positions:

    • During low-volume periods, manipulators may create artificial volatility to force traders out of their positions.

    • For example, pushing prices down temporarily may scare long holders into selling.

Implications for Traders

  • Risk of Slippage: In low-volume stocks, slippage (difference between expected and executed price) is more pronounced due to liquidity gaps.

  • Use Limit Orders: To avoid falling victim to manipulation, traders should use limit orders rather than market orders.

  • Avoid Off-Peak Trading: Trading during quiet periods increases susceptibility to manipulation.

Conclusion

Price manipulation in low-volume shares is a real risk due to limited liquidity, wider bid-ask spreads, and reduced market activity during off-peak hours. Tactics like stop-loss hunting and pump-and-dump schemes are common strategies used by savvy players or institutions. Traders should mitigate these risks by using limit orders, avoiding trading during quiet periods, and being cautious around key psychological levels like round numbers or recent highs/lows.

Citations:

 

  1. https://www.reddit.com/r/stocks/comments/1d43yv6/why_do_some_stocks_reach_ath_only_during/
  2. https://paperswithbacktest.com/wiki/risks-trading-low-volume-stocks
  3. https://www.marketcalls.in/orderflow/why-your-stop-loss-orders-are-secret-but-still-getting-hunted.html
  4. https://www.investopedia.com/articles/active-trading/051415/risks-trading-lowvolume-stocks.asp
  5. https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/041015/why-trading-volume-important-investors.asp
  6. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/stock-manipulation-techniques-impact-signs-illegal-market-reddy
  7. http://wp.lancs.ac.uk/ffmm2024/files/2024/08/FFMM-2024-034-Jeffrey-Yang.pdf
  8. https://www.cfainstitute.org/standards/professionals/code-ethics-standards/standards-of-practice-ii-b
  9. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1877845
  10. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/Delivery.cfm/5022346.pdf?abstractid=5022346
  11. https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1086/503652
  12. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/q/quietperiod.asp
  13. https://www.steel-eye.com/news/market-price-ramping-what-it-is-and-how-to-identify-this-form-of-market-manipulation
  14. https://www.poems.com.sg/glossary/trading-terms/quiet-period/
  15. https://www.trapets.com/resources/blog/identifying-market-manipulation-5-practical-examples
  16. https://www.tradu.com/en/guide/stocks/does-trading-volume-affect-stock-price/
  17. https://www.reddit.com/r/OptionsMillionaire/comments/18204q2/exiting_large_options_position_when_low_volume/
  18. https://money.stackexchange.com/questions/124018/do-market-makers-try-to-take-out-stop-orders
  19. https://www.reddit.com/r/algotrading/comments/musjhk/any_tips_for_getting_out_of_falling_positions_on/
  20. https://www.investopedia.com/articles/active-trading/051415/rewards-trading-stocks-low-volume.asp
  21. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/stophunting.asp
  22. https://www.reddit.com/r/TradingView/comments/qzuow7/what_causes_huge_price_gaps_in_very_low_volume/
  23. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_manipulation
  24. https://www.reddit.com/r/Daytrading/comments/r2kz5l/how_does_big_price_movement_happen_with_low_volume/
  25. https://phantomtradingfx.com/trading/liquidity-in-the-forex-market-and-how-traders-get-manipulated-into-stop-out-positions/
  26. https://www.topdogtrading.com/stop-running-day-trading/
  27. https://paperswithbacktest.com/wiki/quiet-period-finance-implications
  28. https://researchportal.port.ac.uk/files/58153792/Opening_price_manipulation_and_its_value_influences.pdf
  29. https://money.stackexchange.com/questions/24394/why-can-low-volume-move-a-stock-price-drastically
  30. https://thetradinganalyst.com/low-volume-pullback/
  31. https://www.incrediblecharts.com/trading/stop_loss_trap.php
  32. https://yochaa.com/getting-the-most-of-low-volume-stocks
  33. https://www.aalto.fi/sites/default/files/2019-01/manipulation_of_closing_prices.pdf
  34. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lhPbCJfiCJE
  35. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/l/low_volume_pullback.asp

Identifying stock manipulation during low trading volumes can be challenging, but there are several key indicators to watch for:

Unusual Price and Volume Patterns

  1. Sudden price spikes or drops without fundamental news14

  2. Unexplained changes in average trading volume, especially 5-10% variations from normal levels1

  3. Price movements disproportionate to the stock's typical volatility14

Suspicious Trading Activity

  1. Large trades executed during quiet periods or off-peak hours2

  2. Repeated small trades at specific price levels to create artificial support or resistance3

  3. High volume of trades between a small group of market participants3

Market Sentiment and Information

  1. Unsubstantiated rumors or exaggerated claims on social media and financial forums34

  2. Coordinated negative campaigns by short sellers to drive prices down4

  3. Lack of credible information to justify price movements1

Technical Indicators

  1. Divergences between price and volume trends2

  2. Unusual patterns in on-balance volume (OBV) or accumulation/distribution line (A/D Line)2

  3. Spikes in the Chaikin Money Flow (CMF) indicator without corresponding news2

To protect yourself from manipulation in low-volume stocks:

  1. Use limit orders instead of market orders to avoid slippage2

  2. Be cautious of trading during off-peak hours when manipulation is easier2

  3. Verify information from multiple credible sources before making investment decisions3

  4. Be wary of stocks that rise too quickly without a clear catalyst4

Remember, while these signs can indicate potential manipulation, they are not definitive proof. Always conduct thorough research and consider seeking professional advice before making investment decisions.

Citations:

  1. https://www.nitinbhatia.in/stock-manipulation-retail-investor/
  2. https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/041015/why-trading-volume-important-investors.asp
  3. https://share.market/buzz/learn/red-flags-that-indicate-stock-market-manipulation/
  4. https://intrinio.com/blog/what-is-stock-market-manipulation
  5. https://www.trapets.com/resources/blog/identifying-market-manipulation-5-practical-examples
  6. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tn5Fi4NxoWY
  7. https://smartasset.com/investing/market-manipulation
  8. https://www.repository.cam.ac.uk/bitstreams/cfe70962-1727-4eeb-83e7-fcfb2b6f3d7d/download

Indicators to Identify Manipulation in Low-Volume Stocks

Low-volume stocks are particularly susceptible to manipulation due to limited liquidity and fewer active participants. Here are specific indicators and techniques to help identify potential manipulation:

1. Sudden Price Movements Without News

  • What to Look For: Sharp price spikes or drops that occur without any fundamental news or catalyst.

  • Why It Matters: Manipulators often use large trades to artificially inflate or deflate prices, misleading other traders14.

2. Unusual Trading Volume

  • What to Look For: A sudden surge or drop in trading volume that is inconsistent with the stock's historical averages.

  • Why It Matters: Manipulators may use high-volume trades to create the illusion of demand or supply, especially during quiet periods12.

  • Indicator: Volume Rate of Change (VROC) can help spot abrupt changes in volume28.

3. Erratic Bid-Ask Spreads

  • What to Look For: Wide or rapidly changing bid-ask spreads, especially during off-peak hours.

  • Why It Matters: Thin liquidity allows manipulators to place large orders that distort the spread, influencing price movements artificially14.

4. Discrepancies in Buy/Sell Orders

  • What to Look For: Large buy or sell orders placed far from the current market price (spoofing) or orders that appear and disappear quickly.

  • Why It Matters: Spoofing is a common manipulative tactic used to create false market sentiment13.

5. Divergences Between Price and Volume Trends

  • What to Look For: Price movements that are not supported by corresponding changes in trading volume.

  • Why It Matters: Rising prices with falling volume indicate weak conviction and potential artificial price inflation28.

  • Indicator: On-Balance Volume (OBV) can highlight divergences between price and volume trends8.

6. Unusual Patterns in Technical Indicators

Certain technical indicators can help detect manipulation:

  • Accumulation/Distribution Line (A/D Line): A divergence between the A/D Line and price movement may signal manipulation2.

  • Chaikin Money Flow (CMF): Negative CMF readings during rising prices suggest selling pressure despite apparent bullishness2.

  • Volume Weighted Average Price (VWAP): Trading below VWAP on low volume may indicate selling pressure from manipulators2.

7. Time-Based Patterns

Manipulation often occurs during specific periods:

  • Quiet Trading Hours: Early morning or late afternoon when liquidity is low.

  • End-of-Day Moves: Sudden price changes near market close may be aimed at influencing closing prices for reporting purposes36.

Practical Tips for Traders

  1. Monitor Volume Trends: Use tools like VROC and OBV to track unusual volume spikes.

  2. Cross-check News Sources: Verify whether price movements align with credible news or fundamental events.

  3. Avoid Market Orders in Low Liquidity Stocks: Use limit orders to reduce exposure to erratic price swings.

  4. Be Cautious of Psychological Levels: Manipulators often target round numbers or prior highs/lows where stop-loss orders cluster.

By combining these indicators with vigilance, traders can better identify and avoid falling victim to manipulation in low-volume stocks.

Citations:

  1. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/recognizing-market-manipulation-trading-quantifiedstrategies-bccnc
  2. https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/041015/why-trading-volume-important-investors.asp
  3. https://www.trapets.com/resources/blog/identifying-market-manipulation-5-practical-examples
  4. https://smartasset.com/investing/market-manipulation
  5. https://accountinginsights.org/detecting-and-preventing-stock-market-manipulations/
  6. https://www.nortonrosefulbright.com/en/knowledge/publications/4a15661f/manipulative-trading-practices-a-guide-for-banks-legal-and-compliance-departments
  7. https://www.iosco.org/library/pubdocs/pdf/ioscopd103.pdf
  8. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/l/low_volume_pullback.asp

 

 

 

Buy Depth, Sell-Depth VWAP and Support/Resistance

To understand the interplay between Buy/Sell Depth and VWAP, it's crucial to grasp each concept individually and then see how they combine to provide market insights.

1. Volume Weighted Average Price (VWAP):

  • Definition:
    • VWAP is a trading benchmark that calculates the average price a security has traded at throughout the trading day, weighted by volume.  
    • It essentially shows the "average" price where most volume has been transacted.
  • Significance:
    • Institutional traders often use VWAP to gauge execution quality. If they buy below VWAP or sell above it, they've generally achieved a favorable price.  
    • It also provides a sense of the overall market's average price for the day.

2. Buy Depth and Sell Depth (Level 2 Data):

  • Definition:
    • Level 2 data, or "depth of market," displays the order book, showing pending buy (bid) and sell (ask) orders at various price levels.  
    • Buy Depth: indicates the total volume of buy orders at different price points. It represents the strength of buying interest.
    • Sell Depth: indicates the total volume of sell orders at different price points. It represents the strength of selling pressure.
  • Significance:
    • Buy depth reveals potential support levels, where buyers are willing to step in.
    • Sell depth reveals potential resistance levels, where sellers are likely to emerge.
    • The balance between buy and sell depth can indicate potential price direction.

Interpreting the Relationship:

Here's how these concepts work together to provide insights:

  • Buy Depth and VWAP:
    • If the price is trading above VWAP and there's strong buy depth, it suggests bullish momentum. Buyers are aggressively stepping in, reinforcing the upward trend.
    • If the price is below VWAP, but there's increasing buy depth, it could signal potential support. Buyers may be accumulating, even at lower prices, which could lead to a reversal.
  • Sell Depth and VWAP:
    • If the price is trading below VWAP and there's strong sell depth, it indicates bearish pressure. Sellers are dominating, pushing the price lower.  
    • If the price is above VWAP, but there's increasing sell depth, it could signal potential resistance. Sellers may be looking to offload their positions, potentially halting the upward trend.

Combining the Data for Price Direction:

  • Strong Buy Depth Above VWAP: Strong bullish signal.
  • Strong Sell Depth Below VWAP: Strong bearish signal.
  • Divergence:
    • If the price is below VWAP, but buy depth is increasing, it could be a sign of accumulation, potentially leading to a reversal.
    • If the price is above VWAP, but sell depth is increasing, it could be a sign of distribution, potentially leading to a reversal.

Important Considerations:

  • These are just indicators, not guarantees.
  • Market conditions, news events, and other factors can significantly impact price movement.  
  • Level 2 data can change rapidly, requiring quick analysis.  
  • It is very important to remember that large orders can be placed, and then removed, to create false signals.

By analyzing the interplay between buy/sell depth and VWAP, traders can gain a more nuanced understanding of market dynamics and potential price direction.

Follow donncha@runprofits.com:
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments